Underemployment Among College Graduates: Half of College Graduates Working High School-Level Jobs

The Unexpected Reality: Half of College Graduates Working High School-Level Jobs

Understanding the Scope of Underemployment Among College Graduates

Underemployment Among College Graduates

The scope of underemployment among college graduates is a pressing issue, with a staggering 52% of recent graduates finding themselves in such a predicament within their first year out of college. This figure remains alarmingly high, with 45% still underemployed a decade after graduation. Underemployment, in this context, refers to positions that do not require a bachelor’s degree, and the trend is persistent—73% of those who start in underemployed roles continue in similar positions ten years later.

• Prevalence and Persistence:
  • 52% of recent graduates underemployed in the first year post-graduation.
  • 73% of those underemployed at the start remain so a decade later.
    
    The situation is exacerbated by economic shifts, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, which saw underemployment rates for recent college grads spike, although they have since returned to pre-pandemic levels. Yet, the long-term outlook is concerning, with only 34% of underemployed graduates aged 22 to 27 securing “good non-college jobs,” a significant drop from the 1990s. Moreover, the share of graduates in low-wage jobs has increased over the years.
• Economic Shifts and Long-term Outlook:
  • COVID-19 Impact: Temporary spike in underemployment rates.
  • Long-term Earnings: Decline in “good non-college jobs” and increase in low-wage employment.
    
    Gender disparities also play a role, as women are more likely to be underemployed than men. This disparity highlights a need for targeted strategies to support female graduates in securing appropriate employment. Additionally, the median salary gap between underemployed graduates and their fully employed counterparts stands at $10,000, emphasizing the economic disadvantage that underemployment can entail.
• Gender Disparities and Economic Disadvantage:
  • Gender Gap: Higher underemployment rates for female graduates.
  • Salary Gap: Median salary difference of $10,000 between underemployed and fully employed graduates.
    
    The challenge of underemployment for college graduates is not just a statistic; it reflects the mismatch between education and job market demands. This reality underscores the importance of aligning higher education with career pathways that offer fulfillment and financial stability.

Factors Contributing to the Underemployment Crisis

The underemployment crisis among college graduates is multifaceted, with various factors contributing to this disconcerting trend.

• Global Perspective:
  • The surge in college graduates in developing countries is a double-edged sword. While higher education is crucial for economic growth, it can also lead to increased underemployment and overeducation if not met with corresponding job market opportunities. Each country’s specific economic and social factors are critical in determining the outcome for these graduates source.
• Economic Discrepancies:
  • Despite an overall growing economy, not all sectors experience this growth equally. Some industries may flourish while others stagnate, leading to a mismatch in job availability. This uneven distribution can result in underemployment, particularly in not expanding fields. Moreover, standard government unemployment statistics may not fully capture the extent of underemployment, potentially painting an overly optimistic picture of job availability source.
• Credential Inflation and Economic Pressure:
  • Credential inflation has become a significant factor as the value of a bachelor’s degree diminishes with the increasing number of graduates. Employers often raise the bar for entry-level positions, which can leave college graduates working high school-level jobs. Additionally, the burden of student loan debt can force graduates to accept any available job to begin loan repayment, regardless of the job’s relevance to their field of study or the required level of skill source.
    
    These elements underscore the complexity of the underemployment issue facing college graduates, revealing the need for a more nuanced approach to higher education and job market preparation.

The Economic and Psychological Impact of Underemployment

The economic and psychological effects of underemployment among college graduates are profound and multifaceted, impacting both immediate financial circumstances and long-term well-being:

Economic Impact:

1. Income Disparity: On average, underemployed recent graduates earn an annual salary of $60,000, 50% less than those in college-level jobs, yet 88% more than individuals with only a high school diploma.
2. Long-Term Earnings: Underemployment leads to a 17% lower wage compared to fully employed peers, and this income gap can widen over time, jeopardizing financial stability and career progression.
3. Student Loan and Retirement: The ability to pay off student loans and save for retirement is hindered, with underemployed graduates earning 40% less per week than their peers in jobs requiring a bachelor’s degree, complicating the management of student loan debt, which on average constitutes 20% of a graduate’s income.
   
   Psychological Impact:

• Mental Distress: Emotional distress and reduced job satisfaction are prevalent, with 46% of underemployed graduates reporting frequent mental distress, leading to lower self-esteem and increased depression.
• Workplace Disengagement: A lack of motivation and engagement at work can exacerbate mental health issues, as graduates feel their potential and education are not fully utilized.
• Home Return: Approximately 80-85% of graduates return to their parent’s home after graduating due to financial instability, which can give rise to emotional and psychological disorders, including feelings of worthlessness and a lack of dignity source.
  
  The transition from college to the workforce is daunting for many, and the lack of appropriate coping skills can result in fear, anxiety, depression, and low self-esteem. The underemployment of college graduates fails to capitalize on their education and contributes to a cycle of economic and psychological challenges that can have lasting effects on the individual and society.

Major-specific Employment Trends

The employment landscape for college graduates is marked by significant variations based on their field of study, with some majors leading to more prosperous career paths than others. Here’s a closer look at major-specific employment trends:

• Field of Study and Earnings: According to the NCES, median annual earnings for bachelor’s degree holders vary considerably across different fields. For instance, engineering majors typically command higher salaries compared to those in the humanities or arts. This data underscores the importance of aligning one’s education with market demands to maximize economic returns bachelor-degree holder outcomes.
• California’s Workforce Skills Gap: The projected skills gap in California highlights the need for college graduates across most occupational categories. By 2030, the state anticipates a significant shortage of college-educated workers, especially in sectors that require higher levels of education. This gap suggests that students should consider fields with strong job growth, such as technology or healthcare, to enhance their employment prospects California’s economic progress.
• National Employment Outcomes: The NACE First-Destination Survey provides a national perspective on college graduate outcomes. For the Class of 2022, employment rates bounced back to pre-pandemic levels, indicating a recovering job market. Graduates should be aware of these trends and may find it beneficial to target industries with robust recovery and growth NACE’s First-Destination Survey.
  
  These insights reflect the dynamic nature of the job market and the critical role of education in shaping career success. College graduates working high school-level jobs may need to reassess their career strategies in light of these trends, leveraging internships and practical experience to bridge the gap between their education and the evolving demands of the labor market.

Strategies to Combat Underemployment

To effectively combat the underemployment of college graduates, several strategies can be implemented to bridge the gap between education and employment:

• Regulatory Measures:
  • Ensuring comprehensive information on university quality and graduate employability can prevent resource wastage in low-return educational investments. This requires regulatory oversight to maintain higher education institutions’ quantity and quality.
• Enhanced Internship Access:
  • Paid internships are instrumental in fostering a prepared and productive workforce. Expanding access to these opportunities allows students to gain valuable experience that aligns with their career aspirations.
• Professional Experience:
  • Encouraging students to seek professional experiences throughout college can build important relationships with employers. These early experiences are pivotal in setting the stage for future employment opportunities.
• Alumni Engagement:
  • Better mentoring can be achieved by connecting students with alumni through various channels, such as guest lectures, speaking engagements, and professional assignments. This allows students to work on real-world projects and gain insights from those who have navigated the path before them.
• Career Exploration:
  • Early career exploration, starting as early as the freshman year, enables students to identify suitable roles and effectively position themselves in their professional pathways.
• Practical Skill Demonstration:
  • Companies can improve hiring outcomes by offering more opportunities for students to demonstrate their skills in practical settings. This includes Micro-Internships, on-campus consulting engagements, and other experiential learning opportunities.
• Informed Major Selection:
  • College students can minimize underemployment risks by selecting their major wisely, complementing their education with short-term certificates that emphasize quantitative skills, completing internships, considering graduate school, and opting for starting jobs with better long-term prospects.
• Policy and Institutional Support:
  • Implementing policy changes and providing institutional support such as increased opportunities for paid internships, detailed data about economic outcomes of degree programs, personalized education-to-employment coaching, and funding for high-cost degree programs with strong employment outcomes can significantly enhance employment prospects for graduates.
• Comprehensive Career Services:
  • Offering comprehensive career counseling programs, aligning curricula with industry needs, focusing on soft skills development, promoting work-based learning, and encouraging lifelong learning are essential in reducing underemployment among college graduates.
    
    By integrating these strategies, stakeholders can create a more robust and responsive system that addresses the immediate challenges of underemployed college graduates and lays the groundwork for a more prosperous and equitable future workforce.

The Role of Internships and Practical Experience

In the face of a tight labor market, internships and practical experience have become critical for college graduates seeking to avoid underemployment. The changing employer mindsets are reflected in the estimated 1.4 million jobs projected to be available to workers without college degrees in the forthcoming years. This shift underscores the importance of internships as a strategic tool for graduates to gain the necessary experience and stand out in the job market.

Internship Participation and Outcomes:

• Paid Internships: A substantial 60% of interns are compensated, with an average hourly wage of $20.82, demonstrating the value placed on their contributions.
• Field-Specific Experience: Over two-thirds of students undertake internships to acquire expertise in their chosen fields, engaging in analytical work, problem-solving, and project management.
• Employment Prospects: Paid interns have a significant advantage, with about twice the likelihood of receiving a job offer post-graduation compared to their non-intern counterparts, averaging 1.61 job offers.
  
  Internship Offers and Conversion Rates:
• Full-Time Offers: A remarkable 68% of interns are extended full-time job offers from their internship companies, with over 90% conversion at firms like PwC.
• Paid vs. Unpaid: Paid interns have higher chances of employment and receive more job offers than unpaid interns, highlighting the tangible benefits of compensated internships.
  
  Internship Trends and Diversity:
• Hybrid Internship Models: Employers increasingly favor hybrid internships, with a notable 22.6% increase in intern hiring projections for the academic year 2021-22.
• Underrepresentation in Paid Internships: There is a disparity in access to paid internships, with racial/ethnic minorities, women, and first-generation students being underrepresented.
  
  Predictors of Career Success:
• GPA and Internship Experience: The combination of a strong GPA and the total number of internships completed are major predictors of favorable initial career outcomes for graduates.
  
  These insights reveal that internships serve as a crucial bridge for college graduates to transition successfully from education to employment, mitigating the risks of underemployment. By leveraging internships, graduates can gain the practical experience and industry connections that are increasingly valued in today’s evolving job market.

Learn how you can work with Dr. Rick Wallace on a 1-on-1 basis!

Conclusion

In the shifting landscape of today’s job market, the underemployment of college graduates remains a complex challenge that calls for a targeted and strategic response. The persistence of this issue not only impacts individuals economically and psychologically but also carries broader implications for the efficiency of the job market and the economy at large. A concerted effort, encompassing enhanced internships, real-world experience, and informed educational choices, can align graduates’ talents with suitable career opportunities, thereby unlocking the full promise of higher education.

As graduates navigate this terrain, they must consider unconventional economic empowerment paths. Exploring opportunities to augment their market value beyond the confines of traditional employment can pave the way to financial independence and stability. Enhancing one’s skill set to generate revenue through diverse channels can be invaluable in pursuit of such autonomy. Embark on a transformative journey with the Legacy Wealth Academy’s Path to Generational Wealth Course, and kickstart your legacy by signing up for the 7-Day Online Business Launch Course, fostering the skills necessary to create multiple streams of income online.

FAQs

1. What is the likelihood of college graduates working in their field of study?
Only 46% of college graduates work in the field of study they pursued in college. About 29% are employed in a different field, and 16% of individuals under 54, who are not likely to be retired, are currently unemployed.

2. How common is underemployment among college graduates?
A decade after completing college, roughly half of the graduates are underemployed. Despite the common perception that a college degree leads to professional success and upward economic mobility, this is not the case for many graduates.

3. Do college graduates generally feel more satisfied with their jobs thanwith those with only a high school diploma?
Yes, individuals with a college degree tend to report higher job satisfaction levels compared to those who only graduated from high school. Specifically, 92% of college degree holders express being very or somewhat satisfied with their jobs, as opposed to 87% of high school graduates.

4. What is a major advantage for U.S. workers withmany a college degree over those with just a high school diploma?
Workers with a college education typically earn significantly more than those without one. The median annual earnings for individuals with a bachelor’s degree are $36,000, or 84% higher than for those whose highest level of education is a high school diploma. Furthermore, the income gap between college graduates and those with less education is growing.

Additional Reading:

Navigating the Money Maze: 8 Common Financial Issues U.S. Families Are Facing Today

Mastering Your Finances: The 7 Key Steps to Achieve True Financial Freedom